Was This A Positive October Jobs Report? – Vintage Value Investing

The post Was This A Positive October Jobs Report? appeared first on UPFINA – Pursuit of Truth in Finance & Economics.
Both the Markit manufacturing PMI and the ISM manufacturing PMI had weak October readings, but they improved. When these indexes go from weak to okay, that’s a great signal for stocks. That’s why the industrials sector rallied 2.18% (on Friday) and is very close to its January 2018 record high. The graphic below shows that when the ISM PMI is below 50.7 and the prices paid index is below 53.9, stocks perform the best.

Historically, now is great time to buy stocks. The bearish counterpoint is stocks are up from when the downcycle started. Stocks fell in Q4 2018, but since then they have more than recovered. The problem for bearish investors is it’s tough to bet against the cycle based on a valuation call. If the manufacturing sector really did bottom, the probability is that stocks go higher even with tepid economic growth.
Markit Manufacturing PMI Hits 6 Month High
The Markit manufacturing PMI improved from 51.1 to 51.3which is a 6 month high. Both the new orders and production indexes hit 6 monthhighs. The new orders index has increased for 5 straight months. The backlogsindex ended its 3 month decline streak as it was flat. Manufactures had themost confidence on 1 year output growth since June. The increase in new orderscaused pre-production inventories to fall at the quickest rate in 3 months.
The report stated that “Firms noted that their clients were exhibiting less hesitancy in placing orders and market conditions had improved.” The improved conditions were either cyclical or because of confidence about the potential trade deal. The comments section stated, “Tentative signs of renewed vigor are appearing in the US manufacturing sector, with the survey’s production gauge having now risen for three successive months to suggest that the soft patch bottomed out in July.” The recently bearish Markit report suggesting a bottom occurred is amazing news.
ISM PMI Improves Modestly
As anticipated by the regional Fed manufacturing reports,the ISM PMI improved. It went from 47.8 to 48.3 which is consistent with 1.6%GDP growth. It missed estimates for 49.3. It wasn’t a good reading, but itshowed some green shoots. The new orders index rose 1.8 points to 49.1 whichstill signals a contraction. 5 of 18 industries had new orders increase.
The production index fell 1.1 to 46.2. Even with the GM strike, the employment reading increased 1.4 to 47.7. The export orders index rallied 9.4 points to 50.4 and the imports index fell from 48.1 to 45.3. The prices index fell 4.2 points to 45.5. Three of ten firms mentioned tariffs or the trade war in the comments section. A computer & electronic parts firm stated, “Customer demand is down, and we are expecting a very soft fourth quarter, without much relief in sight for Q1.”
Very Strong Jobs Report
The October jobs report was really strong. Fears of theslowdown ending the streak of positive job creation were way overblown. Thisreport was strong because August job creation was revised from 168,000 to219,000 and September job creation was revised from 136,000 to 180,000. That’sa 95,000 increase. Plus, job creation beat estimates in October. There were128,000 jobs added which beat estimates for 90,000. This report was suppressedby the GM strike.
As you can see from the chart below, there were 36,000 jobs lost in manufacturing.

Job creation would have been 6,000 without the strike (which is over now). Overall job creation would have been 170,000. That’s 3 straight very strong readings. The most concerning aspect of this report is professional and business only added 22,000 jobs. This is where you see the cyclical weakness. The government lost 3,000 jobs which means private sector job creation beat estimates by 41,000.
Leisure & Hospitality Drives Job Growth
The biggest criticism of this report is it was boosted byleisure and hospitality which is the lowest paying industry. This industry wasresponsible for 46.6% of job creation in October. You can see in the chartbelow, leisure & hospitality jobs only pay $16.69 per hour. The all-importanteducation and health services industry pays slightly less than the average of$28.18.

To be fair about the criticism of leisure and hospitality creating a high percentage of jobs in October, the percentage would have been less if it wasn’t for the GM strike. If there would have been 170,000 jobs created, the industry would have created 35.9% of the jobs. In the last 3 months, this industry has added 154,000 jobs. As you can see from the chart below, the 3 month annualized growth rate is 3.7%.

Level Of Job Creation Necessary To Maintain UnemploymentRate
The unemployment rate rose from 3.5% to 3.6%. The underemployment rate rose from 6.9% to 7%. As you can see from the chart below, at a labor force participation rate of 63.3%, job creation of 80,000 will maintain the unemployment rate. Job creation has been way above that in the past 3 months. The 3 month average is 176,000 (ex-GM it is 190,000). This implies there’s still some slack left in the labor market. 

The break-even pace of monthly jobs growth – pace at which unemployment holds steady at the current 3.6% for the present participation rate (63.3%) – is 80k (green), half our estimate of actual underlying jobs growth (150k). Unemployment will keep falling below the Fed’s forecast pic.twitter.com/CFJaTbYQY4
— Robin Brooks (@RobinBrooksIIF) November 1, 2019

Maybe We Are At Full Employment
The labor force participation rose from 63.2% to 63.3% whichbeat estimates by 0.2%. That’s the highest rate since August 2013. The primeage labor force participation rate rose from 82.6% to 82.8% which is thehighest rate since August 2009. This matches the expansion high. As you can seefrom the chart below, the demographically adjusted employment to populationratio has reached the 1999-2000 average. This implies the labor force is nearfull employment.

Strong Wage Growth
Average hourly wage growth in September was revised up 0.1% to 3%. October’s wage growth was the same as this revised reading. That’s actually a really nice improvement in the 2 year growth stack because growth improved sharply last October. The 2 year stack went from 5.98% to 6.36%. Weekly wage growth changed about the same because the length of the work week was steady at 34.4 hours. Average weekly wage growth was 2.74%. That’s off the cycle peak of 3.63%, but inflation is also down, so it’s not as much of a problem for real wage growth. The October CPI report comes out on November 13th. Low wage workers continue to have the highest wage growth as production and non-supervisory wage growth was 3.49%.
The manufacturing PMIs were weak and improved modestly. This could be the start of something great for stocks because when data goes from bad to okay, it’s a huge positive. Stocks do better when the ISM PMI is weak. The October jobs report was really good because of the positive revisions and the estimate beat. Job growth would have been even better without the GM strike. The biggest criticism of this report is too high of a percentage of job creation came from leisure and hospitality. 
The post Was This A Positive October Jobs Report? appeared first on UPFINA.

Source link